Do you know what you want?
Have you ever stood at the edge of a big change and thought, “I just don’t know what I want”?
Maybe the career you worked so hard for doesn’t fit anymore. You can feel that there’s more, but every time you try to name it, you go blank. So you make a pros and cons list. Or you jump at the next certification that looks exciting. Neither one sticks.
We’ve noticed that “I don’t know what I want” is often a defense. If we don’t know, we don’t have to change.
There’s a deeper question underneath. The next time you catch yourself asking “What do I want?”, stop and ask yourself…
Who is asking?
The confusion isn’t a sign that something is wrong with you. It’s a sign that the old self is no longer the one who should answer.
If you want to become a life coach and wonder how you can help others, listen to our recent JUNG ON PURPOSE podcast episode (previously named Soul Sessions) to explore how our unique Jungian coaching model is the future of coaching.
- Why “I don’t know what I want” can be a defense. Like rescued gorillas hesitating at the edge of open grass, we stay in the familiar box even when something better is right outside.
- Why logic and shiny objects both fail. Pros-and-cons lists and impulsive leaps are both run by an ego that wants to stay safe.
- How your brain builds the world you see. Neuroscience shows that our reality is actively constructed, which means real change starts on the inside.
- What higher knowledge is, and why one path matters. Picking from every tradition keeps us digging shallow holes; following one path all the way leads to the witness, the Self.
- A daily practice for self-inquiry. Sit with one profound question you can’t answer yet, and notice what starts to show up.
Get coaching with Debra & Dr. Rob in our new Coaching Membership – Second Horizon.
Group coaching (private upgrades available) for mid-life professionals seek deeper meaning and live out their big vision. Join us each month with live calls, exercises, meditations plus a library of on-demand courses on all topics for your life.
If you want us to explore a topic or answer a question, please comment below. We’d love to answer your questions on a future podcast!
Stay Connected with Debra and Dr. Rob:
Instagram | LinkedIn | YouTube | Facebook | creativemindlife.com | connect@creativemindmethod.com
Episode Transcript
00:00 How do you know what you really want?
Debra (00:00)
Hello everyone, welcome to Jung on Purpose. I am Debra Maldonado.
Dr. Rob (00:04)
I’m Dr. Rob. Welcome to the podcast.
Debra (00:07)
And today we’re going to answer a simple question in a difficult way. The question is, how do you know what you really want? People at midlife are at a turning point in their life, that second part of life. They know what they created up until now isn’t it, but they’re still in that place of not knowing what’s next. And we can all relate to that.
But the question is not really what you want. Before you answer that question, you have to ask yourself who is asking the question. And so we’re going to go into that today. And before we begin, I do want to remind you to click subscribe if you’re watching us on YouTube. It’s in the corner. Also like and comment below. And if you are watching us or listening to us on any of the podcast services, we appreciate you subscribing to our podcast so we can reach more people. Thank you very much.
So what does it mean, Rob, who’s asking the question?
Dr. Rob (01:11)
Yeah. It is essentially, who is the person, or what is it, that is looking out at your life and experiencing this world?
Because if you notice, the first half of our life is oriented externally. When we’re young, the world is a new experience to us. Everything is new and therefore we want to devour it. We want to experience as much of it as possible. And of course, the social pressure.
Creating something for ourselves, whether it be a career or a family, or both, those things always take us outward into the appearance of the world.
Debra (02:14)
And also a lot of our clients are professionals. They have achieved, it’s about achieving the degrees, the advanced degrees, about moving up the corporate ladder or gaining some kind of external achievement in the world. And we’re all driven that way since we’re kids, to succeed in life, right? To do all the right things. So there’s nothing wrong with that. It’s just that we make that decision unconsciously.
And what we choose is mostly what our family tells us or society tells us we should choose. Don’t be an artist, they don’t make any money. Go find a good job, go find a steady job, right?
Dr. Rob (02:54)
Were you talking to my father?
Debra (02:58)
Yes. I remember when I was in my stage of trying to figure out what’s next. Every time I had an idea, like, I was a marketing executive and I said, I want to go to massage school. And my mother’s like, that is ridiculous. You’re going to work in a massage parlor. She thought I was going to be some floozy. I’m like, Mom, it’s not like that. And then when I wanted to be a hypnotherapist, she’s like, what is that? That’s crazy. People are going to think you’re crazy. Why don’t you just get a real job?
And so it’s really funny. My family and the people around me, even my friends, would be like, are you going to make any money doing that? Are you sure? You have such a great job, you should be happy. And I think that’s the idea, that everyone else is telling you, you should be happy with what you have. Why should you be unhappy? And no one understands that if you’re not doing what you love according to your choice, it’s not fulfilling at all, because you’re not doing it from a true place.
And a lot of times we don’t know why we feel that way. And that’s really what we are going to talk about today.
Dr. Rob (04:08)
Yeah, because around midlife in general, right? There are different models of development and stages, but let’s just make it simple. Somewhere around midlife, you start to question, is this all there is? Is there more? What is my purpose? Who am I beyond what I’ve created, as a social creature, as the career, as the role?
Debra (04:45)
And there are certain stages where you don’t realize it’s a problem yet, even though it is. We have that pre-contemplation stage of change where we’re not even thinking about it. Maybe on the periphery we feel a little unsatisfied, but we haven’t really pinpointed it yet. And a great metaphor I can think of: they looked at these gorillas that were in a lab their whole life, in cement cells.
It was animal testing. It was terrible. And so these rescuers, I think it was in Australia, decided to rescue these gorillas. And the animal rights people said you can’t just put them in the grass because they’re not used to it. You have to transition them. So they put them in these cells that had one wall down that led out to this beautiful natural environment with trees and sunshine and grass.
And they stayed in their cells for so long. They followed this one gorilla, and he put his little toes out on the grass and then pulled back. He was out there for a little bit and he just didn’t feel like it was safe. It took a long time to coax them out. And then they started to play and realize, wow, this is so much better than that cell. But if we think about our lives, we’re in this cement box of what we think other people want. And we are so afraid of the unknown. Even if it’s better, we’re so afraid of it.
And so I think the confusion stage, “I don’t know what I want,” is a defense, don’t you think? If you don’t know what you want, you don’t have to make a change, right? You could just be in that discovery phase.
Dr. Rob (06:30)
It can be, right. Yeah. We know there is always resistance in growth in general. Spiritual growth is not the exception. There’s always resistance in spiritual growth as well.
Debra (06:53)
And is it because of the unfamiliar, would you say? I know there are many different reasons, but why do we resist change? Why do those gorillas not want to be in this natural, beautiful place that’s actually better than the cell?
Dr. Rob (07:06)
Yeah, I think it’s a little bit different, because in spirituality what we’re going to be asked to do is to leave our old self-concept behind. And that is difficult for the ego to relinquish.
Debra (07:30)
So it’s a little more complex with a human being.
Dr. Rob (07:33)
Exactly, because the ego’s main purpose is to keep our sense of self intact. That seems to be its primary function. Above all, help this mind-body survive and keep that identity intact, so that the individual has a container to experience the world in, instead of just chaos. There’s a cohesion.
There’s a narrative that goes along with our story, right? We experience our life in sequence and we have memories.
We know in neuroscience now the understanding is that our brain is really designed to predict what’s going to happen next. It’s a predicting machine. And so it goes by past assumptions as to what can I expect from the world? What can I expect from today?
Debra (08:32)
So it almost has a plan and a system in place for every scenario you’ve lived up until now, and you feel that comfort in knowing how you can manage it.
Dr. Rob (08:42)
Yes, the more predictable things are, the safer we feel. But there’s also a need for growth. We want to explore, we want to grow, and that’s where spirituality comes in. And by spirituality I don’t mean religious ideas per se, but more that need to connect to something bigger than our persona, our ego, our role.
Debra (09:13)
And so we talk about how it’s not really what people think: if I change what I want, then my life will change. But you have to change who’s wanting. And when we talk about that, the ego, this conditioned self, has a very different agenda than your true self, which is this part of you that, we like to call it the unlived self, this other part of us that hasn’t really lived to its full potential.
09:41 Why logic and shiny objects won’t tell you what you want
Debra (09:41)
And so I think some of the time people think, if I just rationally think about this, the pros and cons and what’s the best next career for me, what makes sense to me, or you’re looking outward trying to figure it out. That’s a mistake. And then the opposite of that is the shiny object syndrome. You see these certifications everywhere, or I want to be a mediator, I want to be a coach, or I want to be a nurse or whatever, and you’re just reacting. That sounds fun, or I want to be an influencer on Instagram, and your emotions are carrying you. Both the extreme logic and the emotion are ego driven. It feels rational, but if the ego is using the rational mind, it’s using it for: how do I prevent any danger happening to me, or me failing? How do I keep myself safe? And I think the problem is that it’s messy when we change, right? That exploration is messy.
Dr. Rob (10:48)
Well, yeah, it’s going to topple a lot of our cherished conceptions of what the world is and what our life is about, and that’s why there’s so much resistance. But there is also the element of the unknown, because you’re entering the mystery. Jung says we are an enigma to ourselves. That’s an understatement, really. We don’t know much about ourselves, right? We try to figure it out through biology, we dissect the body, try to understand the brain. We’ve made some headway, and we understand a lot about the mind now and the brain, but we still don’t know the essential questions. Like, what is life?
A lot of people are surprised that we don’t really have a good definition of what life is. What makes the difference between a living person and a corpse? Where is that?
Debra (12:01)
And what makes a good life? What defines that? I see a lot of people who are entrepreneurs, and their story is, I grew up poor, and so I’m going to make a lot of money so I don’t repeat that. And they think that’s some kind of divine mission, which I can see, that makes sense. But it’s coming from a response to early conditioning. So it’s really not a choice.
Just like, I grew up in a terrible household, so I want to go and empower people to have better lives, or maybe help parents be better parents. Great. That’s a great logical thing, but you’re also basing it on a reaction to something. So it’s not really complete freedom. You’re making it based on your conditioning, in some way compensating for something you didn’t have by giving it to someone else. And again, this is very altruistic. It’s very wonderful to do that. But is it really your choice? And you see this in wellness workers, healthcare workers. They had that “I want to help others,” and they’re burnt out. How many therapists talk about how burnt out they are with all the clients, trying to carry everyone’s stuff? That’s where you start to question.
There’s a part of me that wants to do it, but am I doing it from ego, from a limited concept?
Dr. Rob (13:35)
Yeah. So let’s talk about how people can think about this process of shifting from this ego-centered self, the typical experience of most human beings, into this searching and then into this finding, because we don’t want to search all our lives. We want to find.
And what is that process of shifting gears, or moving to the next stage of life? As Jung would say, there’s a natural progression. Once you reach a certain point, you want to take time, as the wisdom traditions say, to engage with self-inquiry. Self-inquiry meaning, who am I?
Dr. Rob (14:33)
What is the nature of that “I” that I’m talking about? What is the experience of consciousness teaching me? What is it for?
Debra (14:41)
Also, two other questions: what is the world? And why am I here? Why was I born? Those are questions we ask ourselves early, and then we make assumptions about those questions based on what other people taught us. Religions and culture and family teach us.
Dr. Rob (15:03)
You mean early, like in childhood?
Debra (15:11)
Yes, and childhood. And then even in your twenties, society is telling you what the world is. Well, the world is cutthroat, and it’s hard to make money and you have to work hard, and all these assumptions we make about the world, that it’s outside of us. And then, what am I supposed to do here? We’re told you have to get a steady job, you have to pay your bills, you have to get married, you have to have a good relationship, you have to have all these things. And then we achieve all that and say, well, this isn’t it. It’s wonderful, but it’s not it. There’s still a hole in our life.
And it’s that spiritual part. The outer world is fulfilled, which I think is really important. We want to do that in the first half of life. But then the second half is about going in and filling in that gap of meaning and fulfillment. And that’s only answered if we really know who we are and know the nature of ourselves, our deeper selves.
15:59 Is your reality a hallucination? What neuroscience says
Dr. Rob (15:59)
Yes. And, like you say, the nature of reality. Because if you don’t understand what reality is, you’re misperceiving it. So let’s start with the neuroscience. Anil Seth, the neuroscientist, has a brilliant book called Being You.
Debra (16:17)
I love the neuroscience. I have it here.
Dr. Rob (16:38)
Yeah, Being You: A New Science of Consciousness. And this is just one of the findings. We’re not saying that if you read his work you’ll hear what we’re talking about, but it’s a good resource for understanding where we are as far as neuroscience and the understanding of the brain.
So he says something like this: the senses are not giving us an objective experience of reality. Now, what he means is that reality is not already formed, and then we’re just walking in and experiencing it. Which is how it feels, essentially.
Debra (17:30)
And that it’s static. When we leave the room, it’s still there. There’s an actual room there. That’s what most people believe.
Dr. Rob (17:37)
Exactly. That’s how we experience it, right? It feels like if I leave things on my desk, they’ll be here tomorrow. And therefore, for me, it’s an objective reality: if somebody else comes into the room, they’ll see the same objects on the desk. But really, what’s going on in neuropsychology is this.
We actively construct our realities. In other words, what we call our experience is not independent of our own mind. Our mind is actively shaping, constructing, giving color, form, meaning to that experience. So in essence, he says we’re hallucinating what we call our reality.
Debra (18:34)
Like a dream.
Dr. Rob (18:36)
Very similar to a dream. We’re actively constructing it in the mind. So we could think of it as a mental model that we create of what we assume to be real.
Debra (18:48)
Sometimes people use the word consciousness to mean our waking state. But think of it as two different paradigms we can accept: either we’re in a world that’s created by our minds, or a world that we feel is material. So that would be a really good first step as well. What am I living in? What is this world?
Is it a materialistic world or is it a world made up of mind stuff? And then, if it is, the answer of who am I is going to change as well. I think that’s the first challenge: how do you answer that question? And we don’t want to just believe something. How would someone test that, Rob? We don’t want to just say, Debbie and Rob and this guy Anil say the world is consciousness, let’s just believe them. How would they test it?
Dr. Rob (19:47)
Yeah, so this is something I learned along the way in my studies. In doing analysis, you can think of different levels or different layers. We can think of the biological level as the basic experience of our lives. We wake up and here it is, the body is with us again and the world appears again.
So that biological experience is universal. It’s what we all experience, including animals. Anything that’s alive experiences something similar.
Then we go into the psychological level, which is what we call our mind. Now, our mind is not our brain. And this is difficult for people to understand, because often the brain is used as a symbol for the mind. But the mind, again, is one of those things we do not have a good definition of. There are a lot of different discussions about what it is and how to define it, but there’s no consensus.
Debra (21:03)
Well, the materialists would say that the body creates the mind. The physical mechanisms would create it. But that’s not real either, because if you believe everything is mind, then the mind actually created the body. Consciousness, everything is made out of consciousness. It’s not separate.
Dr. Rob (21:08)
Yes, but that’s how it happens, not what it is.
Debra (21:29)
Because in the material model, your mind, your consciousness, dies with the body, if the body is creating consciousness. So that would be a good question to ask. Do you believe you survive your body? We won’t know the answer to that question until we go, but what do we choose to believe, right?
Dr. Rob (21:54)
Yeah, so if we go back, we have this brain. We can observe it, right? We can dissect a skull and find a brain, but we do not find the mind. So the mind, we can say, is an emergent property of the brain. And this is the perspective in Western science. When you read Anil Seth in his book,
he’s talking pretty much as a hardcore scientist who believes that what we call mind emanates or arises from the brain. Through all the neuronal connections and their chatter back and forth, their communication, voila, we have this thing we call mind, or this experience of mind. But on the other side,
the wisdom tradition side, and for us it’s a much more sophisticated understanding of what consciousness is, their perspective is the opposite. Consciousness is primary. It existed before there were these mind-bodies to experience things. And then arose these biological entities, or the way they appear to us,
that appear to have their own consciousness, but they’re actually borrowing or channeling this consciousness and experiencing the world through it. So it’s a different model from the scientific perspective. Now, we want to understand the scientific perspective, because it’s a great way to study the experiences of the world. It really informs us.
Debra (23:52)
So we can’t deny that there’s an experience of an apparent reality, of the mind coming out of our body, and that we’re separate, my mind is separate from yours. That’s an experience, an experience of being in a physical world. In Eastern philosophy, they call it the apparent reality. So there is that experience. We’re not denying that.
Debra (24:21)
But we’re asking, is there another possibility here than what our senses show us, which is driven by the brain, of what’s really happening?
Dr. Rob (24:35)
Yes. So it’s important to understand these three levels: the biological one, which gives us our understanding of the brain; the psychological one, which gives us our understanding of what we do with that experience. How do we create meaning from those experiences? And how do we use that meaning? Why is meaning so important to us? You know, Jung says…
Debra (25:04)
Would it be the stories that we tell? The psychology is how we describe the world. We see something, and the psychology is how we interpret it?
Dr. Rob (25:15)
Very much so. And we know there is a tendency toward narrative in the human mind, right? We are creatures of stories. When we cannot make sense of something, when it doesn’t fit our narrative, we either exclude it, ignore it, tune it out. The brain just says, I don’t have any way to categorize what I’m experiencing, therefore it doesn’t exist. Or we feel uneasy. We feel like there’s something wrong, something off here, something I cannot fit into my typical narrative of who I am and what reality is.
Debra (26:06)
Well, our reality is constructed by that narrative, because we have events that happen in our life and we make a story about what they mean. And then we also make a story about who we are based on those experiences. So most of how we define ourselves, talking about what we want and who we are, our psychology tells us who we are based on the sum of all our experiences and what we’ve accomplished in the world.
It is a narrative. It’s a myth that we tell ourselves about who we are. And we believe it. We believe I had this terrible childhood, or I got divorced, or I can never find love, or I have health problems, I can never make money, I can never succeed, or I am successful. We have all these labels and stories around our identity.
Debra (27:01)
And that is what keeps us feeling secure, like we talked about. And for us to change, you don’t want to challenge that story. I’ve seen so many people not want to let go of a painful experience of the past to move on, because there’s something so grounding in that pain. It’s almost like they’re identified by the pain and they can’t let go. If I drop this, who am I going to be? So these are the questions people should ask when they say, who am I? Am I the sum of everything that’s happened to me in this body?
Dr. Rob (27:38)
Yeah, so both the biology and the psychology tell us that we are the authors of our life. Now, this is hard for people to accept, because they’re used to seeing the reality of their life as something outside of them, that they have nothing or very little to do with, the way reality is appearing to them. And the neuroscience and the psychology tell us the opposite. You are constructing your reality. You might not be aware of it, but your brain and your mind are creating this hallucination that you call your life. Which means then that if you want to change it, you change it from the inside. You start with your mind, not with the external.
Debra (28:41)
Not “I’ll get another title or change careers or move to another place,” which is what most people do. I’m going to redefine myself. I’m going to cut my hair or let it go gray, or go on a diet, or shave my head, or change my name. Some people do. They change their name to get rid of the past, but they haven’t completely changed the story.
29:07 What is self-inquiry? Asking “Who am I?”
Dr. Rob (29:07)
That’s right. So this is where we get to the third stage, which most people traditionally call spiritual awakening, or searching, or the dark night of the soul, if you will. Any of those patterns or experiences that break the old pattern and make you question, is this really what my life is about?
If I want to make changes, how do I make changes? And that larger question of who am I? What is this thing called my life?
Debra (29:44)
I remember when I was in that stage. Who am I? What do I want to do with my life? Those questions were so powerful. And I think when things blow up in our life, a lot of us have that blow-up moment, a divorce, a loss of a job, or some health crisis that makes us reevaluate, those things are actually the seeds of our transformation. And we think, this bad thing happened to me. But I feel bad for people who stay in their comfort zone their whole life, who live in that same comfort bubble and never get challenged to see that maybe this is not right. So what other people would think is a tragedy in someone’s life might be an opening to something greater. And then when we talk about the spiritual element of it, I’d love to discuss this part.
We hang on so much to this materialistic apparent reality. It’s so important that we keep it all together, and what other people think is real, the house and the title and the relationships. I can’t lose them. It’s so solid. And when we enter that spiritual awakening, we start to realize how unimportant those things are.
How caught up we are in that attachment. Eastern philosophy talks about that: ego attachment, defining yourself by those things. And then we have a freedom. But it is a process. So what would be the first step in that process? “Just be enlightened, everyone.” That’s not the answer. But I think asking who am I? What is the world? And then, what do I want to do with this now that I have this higher knowledge?
I would say the first step is the witness, right? The self-inquiry.
Dr. Rob (31:45)
Yeah, self-inquiry meaning just embracing the questions and taking them seriously, and seeing them as: I need to find answers to these questions, otherwise I’m not fulfilling my purpose in life. Because we are these creatures that have a deep curiosity about the nature of the world.
Dr. Rob (32:15)
The nature of the world always points back to us. Who is the one that’s asking the question? And so we want to know about ourselves.
Debra (32:24)
And the witness is that, right? The witness mind would be the part of us that’s observing, outside the thinking mind, the running mind.
Dr. Rob (32:39)
Yes, but we don’t get to the witness until we undergo this searching to find our path, right?
Debra (32:50)
So you’re saying a spiritual path?
Dr. Rob (32:53)
Well, our spiritual path, right. Because what I’ve seen a lot is pop culture gives people this idea that they can pick and choose from different traditions or different modalities and different techniques and put together this individualized spirituality for themselves.
Debra (33:24)
I’m going to make my own spirituality. I’m going to blend everything together. And I think that’s the spiritual-but-not-religious people, right? They were in an organized religion that was very rigid, and then they said, I want to do everything. Everything is a bright shiny object.
Dr. Rob (33:43)
Yes. And there’s some truth to that. If you look at human culture, it’s always evolving, including religions, including spiritual traditions. But if you look at the core wisdom traditions, and for us the Upanishads are that source, because they’re not really religious, they’re more like spiritual ideas that were written down a long time ago from verbal traditions. Narratives, poems, stories, songs were transmitted orally for many generations. We don’t really know how long, but around five thousand years ago, they started to write them down. And the dates, of course…
Debra (34:40)
And so it’s more of a philosophy than a religion. And there are some, like the Buddhists, there’s the Buddhist philosophy, and then there’s the religion where you are really serious and you’re practicing it as a religion. And of course there are many different schools of Buddhism as well. But I like to look at the first principle, like you say. What’s the common assumption in these ideas? And it’s all about: the mind creates your reality, basically. The physical world isn’t as real as we think it is, our mind is always tricking us, and it’s about understanding how to manage the mind and understand it.
Dr. Rob (35:22)
Yeah. That’s another reason we trust them so much: we see that they understood a lot of the neuroscientific principles that we’re only now in the West finding out for ourselves. They understood these principles well from the beginning, like this idea that our mind creates or constructs our reality.
Debra (35:52)
They called it Maya, right? They had a name for it.
35:56 What is higher knowledge? Why one path matters
Dr. Rob (35:56)
And this leads to higher knowledge. Higher knowledge in the Upanishads is considered knowledge that informs us about that question, who am I? So anything that instructs you on the nature of your true self, that’s higher knowledge. Anything else, simply pointing at external objects or experiences or memories or ideas, is considered lower knowledge. Not bad. We still need knowledge of the world, but it’s not as relevant to the search we’re undertaking. So once the individual begins that search, there are a lot of pitfalls, like we’re saying. If you pick and choose from different religions or different modalities, different spiritual traditions, you’re digging a shallow hole.
It’s like somebody looking for water. They stop, and therefore they don’t reach the water. They start to dig another hole somewhere else and go a little bit deeper there, but not all the way. And that’s how they spend their life. What it leads to is a low-level spiritual experience that doesn’t really hit the mark. It doesn’t go deep enough.
Debra (37:28)
It’s very intellectual. You can say the quotes, but inside, your life really doesn’t change dramatically. You just feel more insightful. For me, and I think people can resonate with this, I think we should all dig shallow holes to figure out what our path is. There’s a stage of that. You don’t want to continue it your whole life. But I remember the reason I dug the shallow hole and stopped was because I got to a place that was uncomfortable.
Debra (37:58)
And I wanted to find something that fit better, that was easier. Human nature, we want it cheap, easy and fast. We don’t want to do the drudgery of studying something long term and really mastering it. We want the quick fixes. And in this society, with AI and technology and attention spans, self-help has become so much about one-time hits, and then something else comes in, this new thing. There’s so much information about psychology and therapy and the mind and consciousness. You spend an hour on Instagram or YouTube and you’re confused. Is this true? Is that true? So you have to really figure it out inside. You test things out. You don’t look at someone who’s famous, who has a bestselling book and millions of followers, and think,
he must know the way, or she must know the way, because they’re so popular. So you have to question everything. You have to stop being a sheep in the world and wake up to: what do I really believe? I think that questioning is really important, questioning what you’re hearing. Question us. It’s very healthy. That’s how you really know, you ask yourself those difficult questions.
Sometimes people will come up to me and tell me what they do, and I’ll say, well, how does that work, actually? And they’re like, I don’t know. It just works. They took a technique and assumed it worked, and they don’t question it at all. And the placebo effect is very powerful, but if we’re really going to know who we are, we have to ask those questions and stop blindly swaying with whatever’s popular this month. And once you figure out what your philosophy is, for us it was Vedanta and understanding consciousness, the root of what we believe, it’s so much easier to look at all this stuff and go, that doesn’t resonate with me. And you talk about the one-pointed mind. I think that’s really important,
to focus on one thing that we believe.
Dr. Rob (40:21)
Yeah, and that one-pointed mind is also related to the one path, and following that path to its conclusion instead of veering off and trying the latest fad.
Debra (40:37)
I remember when we first met, I used to be like, la la la, I read this book. And you were like, well, what is that really about? And I didn’t even question it, it was just interesting. You really taught me a lot when we first met about questioning the pop culture, the pop psychology stuff. Because as a layperson, I assumed, I’m not a psychologist, I don’t know. These people have a label after their name, they must know, they must go by science. And that’s not always true.
Dr. Rob (41:09)
Yeah. And I also say this from my own experience of getting lost in all the bright shiny objects, because I love to learn, and I wanted to learn a lot of everything. But I gradually learned that in these mind-bodies we don’t have all the time in the world. And so to focus and really dedicate yourself to one path is really important.
Dr. Rob (41:39)
And it doesn’t have to be a spiritual tradition per se. It can be a philosophy, like you said. For us, the philosophy of the Upanishads contains this sense of freedom. It’s not constraining. It’s not saying you have to believe this and you have to do things this way. It’s more, I’m going to help you enlighten yourself.
And once you’re empowered enough, you don’t even need us, the text. You can go on your own. That sense of freedom is amazing. You don’t see it very often in other traditions or other scriptures or even philosophies. To me it represents the original experience of humans as they started to realize that they were different from the other animals, and that there was a special purpose to being a human being. And so they started to write these things down. So what is at the heart of this awareness that we call consciousness? Here’s a little passage from a book by our friend Swami Sarvapriyananda, from the non-dual philosophy,
Debra (43:04)
He’s awesome.
Dr. Rob (43:07)
the non-dual Vedanta school. It says: this consciousness never rises or sets, never increases or decreases. It is self-luminous and illuminates everything else without requiring any instrument. It is the ever-present witness.
So that’s what you were talking about earlier. The witness, the witness of life, the observer of our life, including our mind-body, that’s who we really are. That’s the ultimate search we’re moving toward. So this higher knowledge is really useful to us because it instructs us on how to best manage that search, so that we’re not searching all our lives, so that we start to find the ground of being. And we start to realize, this is the real me. This is the real essence of who I am.
Debra (44:27)
And one thing I know from the two of us, we’ve studied and taught this work for twenty years now: Eastern philosophy gives us the concept of what the world is and who we are. And Jungian psychology helps us with the transformation, going from the conditioned self to the true self, making that transition. So I think we need both. You can’t just say, I’m one with everything. I remember hearing that, and how does that work? Or you can get caught up in the psychology of, I’ve got to work on my past and my triggers and my mother complex and all these things, and you can get lost in that and not create something new. Those two really balance each other out, where we know the truth as we’re examining our psychology.
And then the neuroscience is really interesting, because we know the brain is showing us a false reality. So that can help reinforce that we’re not seeing what we think we’re seeing. And it gives us permission to ask questions. We can’t trust our senses and we can’t trust our mind most of the time to tell us the story. So we have to ask questions. And asking the right questions. Not “how do I get more money,” but “why do I want more money? And who is the one that’s asking for more money?” Those questions many times don’t have an answer right away. The deep questions are the ones you ask and don’t get an answer to, and you just sit with them and meditate on them. So I would recommend spending every day thinking of a really profound question about life that you can’t answer.
And just keep asking and meditate on that question. And then you’re going to get the right information. Maybe you found this podcast or this episode because you asked a question, and this is for you. Things will start showing up in your life to give you the answer. And that’s what makes life so powerful and this world so alive, because we’re not in a materialistic world. We’re in a world of the mind, and we can use it to see what we need to see, right?
Dr. Rob (46:49)
Yes. And at the heart of it there’s a contradiction. Because we’re saying essentially you need to search. But the Upanishads are essentially saying there’s nothing for you to gain in your search. You already are that consciousness. It’s like you’re looking for yourself.
Debra (47:12)
But you need to look for yourself when you’re an ego. And then you find yourself and you go, I’ve known this all along.
Dr. Rob (47:23)
Yeah. It’s the snake biting its tail. It leads you back to yourself.
Debra (47:33)
It’s a funny story. There was a search party for this missing man, and the man was a little drunk, and he was walking around with the search party and didn’t realize they were looking for him. So he was looking for himself. That’s the idea. We’re looking for ourselves, and we are who we’re looking for.
Dr. Rob (47:56)
Yeah. But the search is essential. In other words, we do have to step into that inquiry. We become searchers, we become seekers, and we’re on a path. But the path is leading to Self-realization.
Debra (48:19)
Yeah. All right, did we answer the question? How do you know what you really want? The question would be, do you know who you are? And if you know who you are, there really isn’t one thing that you want. When you’re aware of that, there are all possibilities and you get to choose. There’s not one thing you have to choose.
And we go through the process. When we don’t reach enlightenment and figure out our next phase, we’re stepping into the next phase in that searching, and even taking action and trying things on lead us to answer those questions. So it doesn’t mean take a year or two off and go into a cave and figure out who you are and then go out and start your life. No. The things that show up on the way to finding those answers are leading you there.
Debra (49:20)
And so we are going to put in the show notes the books that we mentioned. There’s Meister Eckhart, and one called The Cloud of Unknowing. There’s also one called The Dark Night of the Soul by St. John of the Cross. Thomas Merton, New Seeds of Contemplation. Plotinus. Marcus Aurelius, Meditations.
And in Jung, “The Stages of Life” in Modern Man in Search of a Soul is amazing. I highly recommend that. And of course, for practical success, don’t get turned off by the title, but The Science of Getting Rich is based on Eastern philosophy, very deep, profound philosophy. It’s disguised as materialistic seeking, but it’s a really great read if you read it from that perspective. It’s not about money.
It’s about how you can create what you want and how your mind creates. It’s really, really good. So we will put those in the show notes, and we hope you start asking deeper questions and find deeper answers.
Dr. Rob (50:32)
Yeah. We’ll see you next time.
Debra (50:34)
Take care. Bye-bye.
Listen on
SPEND THE DAY WITH US – 12/5/26!
A Day Inside Jungian Coach Training
Live 1-day Virtual Event to sneak peak the training with Debra & Dr. Rob